CWA Denounces Supreme Court “Five” for Failing to Protect Kids from Internet Porn      6/29/2004

Minors have no First Amendment right to view this kind of porn and smut-peddlers have no right to expose them to it.

Washington – The U.S. Supreme Court today by a 5-4 vote upheld a preliminary injunction against enforcement of the Child Online Protection Act (COPA), which requires commercial content-providers operating on the World Wide Web to restrict access by minors from pornography defined as “material harmful to minors.” The Court remanded the case to the federal district court in Philadelphia for a trial on the merits.

“This is a devastating defeat for kids, parents and the Constitution,” said Jan LaRue, CWA’s chief counsel. “Minors have no First Amendment right to view this kind of porn and smut-peddlers have no right to expose them to it. If COPA involved cigarettes and kids, the law would have been enforced without the threat of any legal challenges. And anybody who opposed it would have been an ash heap. Remember ‘Joe Camel’?”

The Court’s ruling upholds a decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit that held that COPA is likely to be held unconstitutional in Ashcroft v. American Civil Liberties Union. The law does not prohibit Web-site operators from offering pornographic material, but merely requires proof of age before allowing an individual to view material on the Web site.

“COPA requires commercial pornographers to put an electronic blinder rack between kids and porn just as brick-and-mortar businesses are required to do. Adults use credit cards in order to purchase porn on a Web site. However, the Court decided that requiring them to do the same to view the material would likely impose too much of a burden. Hopefully the trial on the merits will prove otherwise.” LaRue concluded.

Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote for the majority and was joined by Justices John Paul Stevens, David Souter, Clarence Thomas and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

For Information Contact:
Demi Bardsley
(202) 488-7000, ext. 1020
media.cwfa.org

Printer Friendly Version

Recent Articles

CWA of Georgia Holds Press Conference Opposing Bill Decriminalizing Prostitution

Read CWA of Georgia Press Conference Statement

Press Release- Decriminalization of Prostitution Not the Answer

CWA of Georgia to Hold Press Conference on February 1, 2010

Bestiality in Primetime, Courtesy of Fox

Open Letter to Georgia Senate Judiciary Committee- Decriminalizing Prostitution

Legalizing Prostitution of Minors in Georgia?

Second Circuit Gets a Second Look at Indecency

CBS Turns "Frosty the Snowman" into Crude Pitch Man for its Sit-Coms

Children and Porn: Always a Bad Combination