CONCERNED WOMEN FOR AMERICA Legislative Action Committee

  • Connect with CWA:

Stay Connected with CWA

As a subscriber to our E-Alerts, you'll be among the first to receive insider briefings, news, and information on the issues that matter most to you and your family. Our emails are concise yet filled with the resources you need to impact public policy in Washington, at your state capitol, or in your own community. Our E-Alerts will equip you to educate, persuade, and motivate others to action. Don't delay! Enroll today!


LBB: Judicial Activism Brings Down DOMA in the Second Circuit

LBB: Judicial Activism Brings Down DOMA in the Second Circuit
By: Mario Diaz, Esq. - 10/26/2012


Welcome to
the Legal Blurb Blog

The latest legal news and commentary from a conservative perspective.

The Second Circuit is now the first court to apply “intermediate scrutiny,” a standard of review typically reserved for discrimination based on gender or legitimacy.

Windsor v. US involves Edith Windsor, a lesbian who married in Canada in 2007, who was residing in New York when her “spouse” passed away in 2009. She then sued when she was denied the spousal deduction for federal estate taxes.

The dissent focused on the essential problem with the majority’s approach:

The majority holds DOMA unconstitutional, a federal law which formalizes the understanding of marriage in the federal context extant in the Congress, the Presidency, and the Judiciary at the time of DOMA’s enactment and, I daresay, throughout our nation’s history. If this understanding is to be changed, I believe it is for the American people to do so.

As the dissent points out, the case “is about the preservation of the traditional institution of marriage and its procreation of children.”

Fortunately that Judge Chester Straub, who wrote the dissent, called out Chief Judge Dennis Jacobs for his activism:

Whether that understanding [of marriage] is to continue is for the American people to decide via their choices in electing the Congress and the President. It is not for the Judiciary to search for new standards by which to negate a rational expression of the nation via the Congress.

Print Friendly

Petition to FCC Chairman Wheeler: Holding the FCC Accountable

Stand with us to protect the American family

Give Now

Young Women for America

ywa sidebar
YWA is a student-oriented initiative that is geared toward high school and college campuses to bring active groups of young like-minded women together to promote conservative values to their schools and the nation.

Learn More